Weathered ivory stucco home with a terracotta roof, arched bronze window and recessed walnut entrance in warm afternoon light.

On Davis Islands, a 100-Year-Old Building Tests What the Land Underneath Is Worth

What happens to a century-old building on Davis Islands when its own owner tells City Council the land is worth more without it?

The Mirasol is finding out. The seven-story building at 84 Davis Boulevard, on the corner of Adalia Avenue, opened as a hotel in the 1920s. It was one of the largest buildings in the community developer David P. Davis planned, and it became apartments in the 1960s. In early October, a wrecking company filed a demolition permit application for it. A few days later, city staff filed for a landmark designation that could stop it. Neither has been decided.

Anyone comparing South Tampa neighborhoods should follow the case closely. It shows that much of the early Davis Islands look buyers pay a premium for has no historic district behind it.

The Owner's Math, on the Record

At a January council meeting, the owner made the land-value case plainly. Bay News 9 reported his words:

"Based on my experience, I can confidently say that a 1.6 acre parcel on Davis Island on the water is worth two-to-three times more without the existing improvements than with them."

According to the same report, he told council that Hurricanes Helene and Milton hit the building hard. He also said that "preserving a historic building, like the Mirasol, costs far more than building something new."

The two-to-three-times figure is one party's estimate, made while asking for a land-use change.

The Vote That Fixed the Use

The owners did not start with demolition. They asked to bring back the building's original use. Their plan would have converted the 58 apartments into up to 118 hotel rooms and a dozen condominiums, with a restaurant and pool, as the Tampa Bay Times reported. The request was a comprehensive-plan amendment changing the land use from R-50 residential to CMU-35 community mixed use, as the Tampa Monitor laid out. Its account also mentions a new building and townhomes in the proposal.

Opposition was organized and large. The Times counted more than 250 people who signed petitions or wrote letters. Hundreds attended a January meeting with five hours of public comment, wearing stickers that read "Save our neighborhood" and shirts that read "Save the Mirasol." Their stated concerns were traffic, parking, noise and construction. On Jan. 15, 2026, council voted 5-2 to deny the amendment, the Times reported. Councilmember Lynn Hurtak made the motion and said the proposed density was inappropriate.

The vote kept the Mirasol a residential building under its existing zoning. The owners had already said that running it as apartments was not financially viable. Council chair Alan Clendenin, who supported the change, saw what that combination could lead to: "If it's not economically viable as an apartment building, it is going to be torn down."

Hurtak raised a separate point at the same meeting, as Bay News 9 reported. Approving the rezoning would not have guaranteed the building's survival, she said, and a historic designation would have made a difference. The Mirasol had none.

Nine Months From Vote to Landmark Filing

The case has moved quickly since January:

  1. 2021. The current owners bought the building, they said, hoping to restore it.
  2. Jan. 15, 2026. Council denies the hotel land-use change, 5-2.
  3. Week of Sept. 28, 2026. A wrecking company files the demolition permit application, first reported Oct. 1.
  4. Oct. 5, 2026. City staff apply for a local landmark designation.
  5. Next. The application goes to Tampa's Historic Preservation Commission. A memo from a senior assistant city attorney, quoted by the Times, says the commission may ask City Council for emergency action after a duly noticed public hearing. That request "would stay all action to issue a demolition permit for the building until a final determination is made."

The commission's next regular public hearing on the City's published 2026 schedule is Nov. 10 at 9 a.m., and the schedule allows for special hearings. No Mirasol hearing date had been made public as of late October. The commission's public hearing agenda page is where one would appear.

The demolition application came first, and the landmark application followed it. Bay News 9 reported that city code triggers this review when someone applies to demolish a building more than 50 years old. The commission can also ask council for emergency action when a building meets certain criteria, including eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places without being listed.

Davis Islands Is Not a Historic District

This is where Davis Islands differs from the neighborhood it's most often compared with. The City's historic district maps show four local districts: Hyde Park, Seminole Heights, Tampa Heights and Ybor City. Davis Islands is not on the list.

Here is the formal protection the island does have:

Tool What it covers on Davis Islands
Local historic district None
Local landmarks, per the City's 2024 designations book Roy Jenkins Swimming Pool, 154 Columbia Drive; Palace of Florence, 45 E. Davis Boulevard; Palmerin Hotel, 115 E. Davis Boulevard
National Register multiple-property document "Mediterranean Revival Style Buildings of Davis Islands," a framework describing a group of 21 buildings
Individually listed example The Spanish Apartments, now Villa de Leon, at 16 E. Davis Boulevard

The City's designations page links to the full 2024 book, with listings by address. The National Park Service document describes a set of buildings. It does not draw a boundary around the island.

On Davis Islands, then, the stucco, arches and tile roofs that set the old streets apart sit outside any local historic district. The Mirasol shows how that plays out on a large waterfront parcel. Neighbors were already wearing "Save the Mirasol" shirts in January, but formal protection for the building was first sought in October, after the demolition application.

Davis Islands and Hyde Park

Hyde Park sits on the City's local district map. Davis Islands does not. The zoning vote kept the Mirasol's use residential and the density where it was, which is what residents asked for. The building itself is a separate question still in front of the Historic Preservation Commission.

Frequently Asked Questions

Has the Mirasol been demolished? No. A demolition permit application was filed in early October 2026, and city staff filed a landmark designation application on Oct. 5. The Historic Preservation Commission's review was still pending as of late October.

Is Davis Islands a local historic district? No. Tampa's four local historic districts are Hyde Park, Seminole Heights, Tampa Heights and Ybor City. The City's 2024 designations book lists three local landmarks on Davis Islands.

Why did council deny the hotel plan? In the January 2026 vote, the majority sided with residents who raised concerns about traffic, parking, noise and density. That vote left the building in its existing residential land use.

Where can I follow the case? The Historic Preservation Commission posts its hearing agendas on the City of Tampa website. Its 2026 schedule lists Nov. 10 as the next regular hearing.

This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm zoning or designation questions about a specific property with the right professional.

Bianca Lopez follows Davis Islands parcel by parcel and can walk you through the designation and land-use record of any property you're considering there. Request Exclusive Access to start the conversation.

Work With Bianca

She is a firm and honest negotiator, and prides herself on knowing the ins and outs of residential contracts, contingencies, and addendum's. This not only helps mitigate your risk, but ensures you get the best deal possible. Contact her today!

Follow Me on Instagram